Home Blog GST GST Simplified by CA Devesh Thakur – Day 9/30 days challenge

GST Simplified by CA Devesh Thakur – Day 9/30 days challenge

0
Day 9 of 30 GST Challenge Value of Taxable Supply
Day 9 of 30 GST Challenge Value of Taxable Supply
Day 9 – Value of Taxable Supply | Sec 15 | CA Devesh Thakur | eTaxSave
🎓 Free Tax Education by CA Devesh Thakur  |  Visit eTaxSave.com  |  All Blogs →
📅 Day 9 of 30  ·  GST Challenge

Value of
Taxable Supply

✍️ CA Devesh Thakur 🌐 eTaxSave.com 📚 GST Series

What exactly is GST charged on? Section 15 of the CGST Act defines the Value of Taxable Supply — the base on which GST is calculated. Normally it is the Selling Price, but Sec 15 prescribes specific additions, deductions, and special valuation rules.

Transaction Value
=
Taxable Value
+
Additions (Sec 15(2))
Deductions (Sec 15(3))
Sec 15(1) Basic Rule Sec 15(2) Additions Sec 15(3) Discounts Sec 15(4) Rules 27–31 Special Valuation
📝 Day 9 — CA Devesh Thakur’s Handwritten Note

📌 Comment ‘YES’ on Instagram to know more + Bonus Video!


🎬 Day 9 Video

Watch Day 9 GST Reel — CA Devesh Thakur

📲 Follow @cadeveshthakur.official for daily GST challenge updates!


💰

What is Value of Taxable Supply?

GST is a percentage-based tax — but a percentage of what exactly? The answer is the Value of Taxable Supply — the amount on which GST is charged. Section 15 of the CGST Act, 2017 defines this comprehensively.

📌 The Core Principle

Hamesha SP = Value of Taxable Supply
“SP” (Selling Price) is NORMALLY always equal to the Taxable Value.
GST is computed on the price actually paid or payable.
⚠️ Aisa Zaruri Nahi — Sec 15 adds/deducts some amounts from SP

Think of it this way — TV = Taxable Value, S = Seller, B = Buyer. The transaction value between them is the starting point, but Section 15 tells us what to add and what to deduct to arrive at the final taxable value.

📋

Sec 15(1) — Basic Rule

Sec
15(1)

Transaction Value = Taxable Value

Applies when two conditions are met simultaneously

The Transaction Value — the price actually paid or payable for the supply — is accepted as the Taxable Value, provided BOTH the following conditions are satisfied:

Seller (S) and Buyer (B) are NOT related persons — no familial, management, financial or other connection that could influence the price
Price is the Sole Consideration — no extra non-monetary benefits, barter elements, or hidden advantages are involved
💡 Example
👤 A (Seller) → sells phone → 👤 B (Buyer) — Not Related
₹20,000 — No extra condition/benefit ★ T.V = ₹20,000

☁️ “Does Not Claim It Back” — Cloud Note

If Buyer (B) pays something on behalf of Seller (S) and does NOT claim it back from the seller, it forms part of the consideration and must be added to taxable value. This links directly to Sec 15(2) additions.

Sec 15(2) — What to “Add” to Value

Sec
15(2)

Five Mandatory Inclusions in Taxable Value

These amounts MUST be added to transaction value even if charged separately
🏛️

Other Taxes (Not GST)

Any other taxes, duties, cesses, fees charged separately — e.g., Custom Duty on imports — must be added to taxable value.

🚚

Expenses Borne by Buyer on Seller’s Behalf

If Buyer (B) pays freight/expense that Seller (S) was liable to pay — and does not claim it back — it gets added. e.g., B paid freight that S was liable for.

📦

Incidental Charges

Charges incidental to the supply such as Commission and Packing charges are included in taxable value.

Interest / Late Fees / Penalty

Any interest, late fees or penalty charged by Seller for Buyer’s delayed payment (e.g., ₹500 extra paid as late charges) is added to taxable value.

💸

Subsidies Linked to Price (Except Govt. Subsidy)

Subsidies given by private parties or NGOs that are linked to the price must be added. Government subsidies are excluded from this rule.

📌 Key Rule for Additions

All five items above form part of the taxable value whether or not they are charged separately in the invoice. The tax base cannot be reduced by billing these items separately.

Sec 15(3) — What to “Exclude” — Discounts

Sec
15(3)

Discounts — When Allowed as Deduction

Treatment differs based on WHEN the discount is given

Discounts may or may not be deductible from taxable value depending on the timing:

Before / At Time of Supply

Pre-Supply Discount

  • Discount given before or at the time of supply
  • Mentioned on the invoice
  • e.g., Trade discount, cash discount shown on invoice
✅ ALLOWED — Deductible from Taxable Value
After Supply (Post-Sale)

Post-Supply Discount

  • Must be as per agreement made before supply
  • Must be linked to the specific invoice
  • Buyer must reverse the proportionate ITC (Input Tax Credit) claimed
✅ ALLOWED — Only if all 3 conditions met

⚠️ Critical — ITC Reversal for Post-Supply Discount

When a post-supply discount is given, the buyer would have already claimed ITC on the full original value. The discount effectively reduces the taxable value — so the buyer must reverse the ITC proportionate to the discount. Without this reversal, the discount deduction is NOT allowed to the seller.

🔍

Sec 15(4) — Transaction Value Not Available

Sec
15(4)

When Transaction Value Cannot Be Determined

Apply Rules 27 to 31 — Use Open Market Value or Cost + % Method

Sometimes the transaction value is not available or not acceptable (e.g., related party transactions, barter deals, no consideration). In such cases, Sec 15(4) directs us to use the GST Valuation Rules (Rules 27 to 31):

📊Open Market Value — what the supply would fetch in the open market at that time
💹Cost + % Method — actual cost of supply plus a reasonable profit margin percentage
📜Rules 27 to 31 — hierarchical set of valuation methods applied in order

Special Valuation — Notified Supplies

For certain notified categories of supply, the Government has prescribed Special Valuation Rules that override Sec 15(1) to 15(4). These rules exist because the standard transaction value approach does not work well for certain high-risk or unique supply types.

🔑 These Rules Override Sec 15(1) to 15(4)

When a supply falls under any of these special categories, the standard Sec 15 rules do not apply. Instead, the specific rule prescribed for that category governs the valuation.

Rule 31A

Lottery & Betting

Special valuation for lottery tickets and betting transactions

Rule 31B

Online Gaming

Valuation for online gaming platforms and virtual digital assets

Rule 31C

Actionable Claims

Casinos and other actionable claim transactions have separate valuation

📌 Comment “YES” to Know More + Bonus Video

As noted on the handwritten note — comment “YES” on the Instagram post to get detailed notes and access the Bonus Video covering special valuation rules in depth. Follow @cadeveshthakur.official on Instagram!

📊

Section 15 — Complete Summary

🧠 The Big Picture — Value of Taxable Supply

  • Sec 15(1) — Basic Rule: Transaction Value = Taxable Value, IF S & B not related AND price is sole consideration
  • Sec 15(2) — Add: Other taxes (not GST), Buyer’s expenses on Seller’s behalf, Incidental charges, Interest/Late fees/Penalty, Private subsidies linked to price
  • Sec 15(3) — Exclude: Pre-supply discounts (always); Post-supply discounts only if: pre-agreed, linked to invoice, buyer reverses ITC
  • Sec 15(4) — Fallback: When transaction value is unavailable — use Rules 27–31 (Open Market Value, Cost + % etc.)
  • Special Valuation: Rule 31A (Lottery/Betting), 31B (Online Gaming), 31C (Casinos) — these OVERRIDE Sec 15(1)–(4)
🔜

Coming Up — Day 10 of #30DaysGSTChallenge

Stay tuned for Day 10! Comment ‘YES’ on Instagram for full notes & bonus video. Follow the full challenge at eTaxSave.com →

NO COMMENTS

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Exit mobile version